Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do I decline a five-star review request when I haven't read my friend's novel yet?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My friend sent the review link with, 'Five stars would really help the launch. You don't need to write an essay.' I haven't started the novel, and she knows that.

I bought a copy because I'm pleased she finished it. I also helped set up chairs at the launch. I thought those were ways to support her while leaving my response to the book until I'd actually read it.

When I said I wasn't ready to review it, she asked whether I was worried it wouldn't be good. That isn't a judgement I can make yet. I simply don't want a public rating to stand in for being glad my friend has published.

How do I say that without turning the refusal into a prediction that I'll dislike the book? I'd like to read it freely, rather than feel that opening the first page means agreeing to produce the result she already requested.

Discussion

5 community replies

'I haven't read it, so I don't have a rating to give. I'm glad you've published, and that's why I bought it and came to the launch.' That explains support you actually offered.

Don't promise five stars after you've finished just to defer the awkwardness. The point is to leave your response undecided until you've had one.

Her question invites you to reassure her about quality you don't yet know. You can reassure her that this isn't a hidden verdict without predicting what your reading experience will be.

Would you enjoy sharing the launch announcement instead? You can tell people your friend has published without describing the novel as something you've read and recommend.

Yes, keep the wording to what you know. A genuine announcement can be supportive without becoming a review written in advance of the reading.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment