Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

How do I decide whether to accept a free piano that would cost $300 to move and tune?

Money category photographMoney

My uncle offered us his piano because he'd love our child to learn on the instrument he played. Saying yes felt like accepting a family memory, not making a purchase.

The moving quote is $180 and an initial tuning quote is $120. Those are the figures in this example, not typical service prices. We haven't had the piano's condition assessed or moved anything. The $300 would come from money reserved for a small family break.

Our child is interested but hasn't started lessons. I don't want to make a promise about years of practice on their behalf, and I don't want my uncle to hear 'we need to think' as a rejection of something meaningful.

What would you check and discuss before accepting, and how would you leave room to decline if the instrument doesn't fit our budget and plans?

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the sentimental offer from the practical decision. Thank him for wanting the piano to stay in the family, then explain that moving, condition and the learning plan need checking before you can commit.

Confirm what the quotes cover and what an assessment would cost before adding more spending. The $300 is the current starting figure, not a verified total for everything you may choose to do.

Talk with your child about the actual interest in lessons and practice without making acceptance of the piano their responsibility. The adults still choose whether the household can take it on.

Could declining mean regretting it later when the child decides they really want to play?

It could, just as accepting could mean spending the break money on an instrument that isn't used. You don't need to eliminate every possible regret. Decide from the interest, condition, space and money you can establish now, and give your uncle an honest answer before arranging transport.

Join the discussion

More in Money