Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I correct my nosebleed advice after insisting my child’s first-aid lesson was wrong?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old was explaining a first-aid lesson and said someone with a nosebleed should lean forward. I interrupted: ‘No, head back. Otherwise the blood keeps coming out.’ She asked me to check. I said I had dealt with nosebleeds for years.

Nobody is bleeding now. We looked it up that evening, and the NHS guidance says to sit down, lean forward and pinch just above the nostrils for 10 to 15 minutes. It also lists circumstances requiring urgent help, including excessive bleeding or bleeding that lasts longer than that. My remembered rule was not reliable advice.

I have told her she was right about leaning forward. She replied, ‘But why wouldn’t you even look?’ That is the question I am struggling with. How do I repair the way I dismissed her without suggesting she should now be responsible for checking every adult’s first-aid knowledge?

Discussion

5 community replies

Answer the part she is still asking about. You relied on having done something before and treated her request to check as unnecessary. Saying that plainly goes further than confirming the correct head position after the argument.

She does not need a speech about how everyone makes mistakes before hearing that this mistake was yours. ‘I should have checked when you asked’ is a complete admission. You can then thank her for bringing the lesson home.

Review the NHS page yourself, including when further help is needed. Correcting one remembered instruction should not turn your daughter into the household first-aid supervisor. The adults still need to know how they will get appropriate help.

Would it help to agree that either of you can suggest checking a factual disagreement? That should be an invitation to find an answer together, rather than a contest in which whoever finds a link wins every argument.

That distinction matters. A household preference is not settled by a medical webpage, and an urgent situation needs action rather than a debate. For a non-urgent factual question like this one, the parent can make checking an ordinary response.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting