How do I change my argument during a seminar without pretending I thought that all along?
EducationI said the character's decision was selfish. A classmate pointed to a passage I had missed, and it changed how I understood the scene. Before I could respond, someone said, “You can't switch sides now.”
This was an open discussion about the novel, not a debate in which we had been assigned positions. I still think the character caused harm, but I am less sure about the motive I confidently gave at the start.
What would be a clear way to revise my argument in the room? I do not want to defend a claim only because I said it first. I also do not want to agree vaguely with the latest speaker and make it look as if the earlier argument never happened.