Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I change my argument during a seminar without pretending I thought that all along?

Education category photographEducation

I said the character's decision was selfish. A classmate pointed to a passage I had missed, and it changed how I understood the scene. Before I could respond, someone said, “You can't switch sides now.”

This was an open discussion about the novel, not a debate in which we had been assigned positions. I still think the character caused harm, but I am less sure about the motive I confidently gave at the start.

What would be a clear way to revise my argument in the room? I do not want to defend a claim only because I said it first. I also do not want to agree vaguely with the latest speaker and make it look as if the earlier argument never happened.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the passage and the part of your claim it changes. You could say that you still see harmful consequences, but the new detail makes your earlier account of the motive too simple. That is a specific revision rather than a change of team.

The classmate who supplied the passage has contributed something useful. Credit that contribution when you explain the shift, while giving your own reason for finding the evidence persuasive.

An open discussion can leave you with a qualified view. You do not have to replace “entirely selfish” with “entirely justified” just because the first account no longer fits.

If your classmate keeps treating the discussion as a contest, bring it back to the text rather than arguing about whether you are allowed to change your mind. Ask what their reading makes of the newly noticed passage.

That keeps the disagreement on something the group can examine. Be open about your earlier position and explain why it no longer covers all the evidence you see. You can reconsider your argument without demanding that the other person make the same change.

Join the discussion

More in Education