Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I change a reward scheme that recognises top grades but ignores my child's progress?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old brought home a much better maths result and asked whether it counted for our family reward. It did not reach the top grade, which is the condition I set. Her older brother had earned the reward the week before.

She said, “Then getting better doesn't matter unless I'm already the best.” I told her progress mattered, but I could hear the mismatch between that answer and the only thing our scheme recognises.

I do not want to take away something her brother has already earned. I also do not want to invent a surprise prize every time someone is upset. The reward is a small choice of family activity, not money they depend on or something needed for school.

How would you retire or revise the scheme fairly? I want to hear what the children think without making them negotiate against each other's results.

Discussion

5 community replies

Acknowledge the improvement on its own terms before discussing the reward rule. Ask what she did differently and which part she feels pleased about. Do not make that conversation an explanation of why she should stop wanting the activity her brother received.

Honour the reward already earned under the old arrangement. Changing your approach does not require telling her brother that his achievement was a problem or that he must give something back.

Say plainly what you have reconsidered: “I made a rule about top grades, but I also care about learning and progress. I need a better way to show that.” You can retire the scheme instead of trying to design a more elaborate scoring table for every subject.

If you create any new goals, agree them before the work happens and discuss them separately with each child. The children should not have to vote on whose improvement is worth more.

That would avoid turning the reset into another competition. You can explain the broad approach together, then ask each child about an appropriate next goal. Keep ordinary family time available too, so every enjoyable activity does not have to be unlocked by a school result.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting