Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

How do I ask for budget advice when Dad's answer is 'we managed on less'?

Money category photographMoney

Dad looked at my budget total and said, 'We raised two children on less than that.' I shut the sheet.

There may be changes I should make. But I need suggestions tied to the rent, travel and grocery figures in front of us, and he thinks I only want advice that agrees with me.

How do I reopen the conversation, invite useful criticism and still keep the final spending decisions mine?

Discussion

5 community replies

Give him a defined task: 'Could you help me find two changes in these current figures and estimate what they would save?' That invites useful scrutiny while keeping the conversation from becoming a verdict on your whole lifestyle.

Ask what his old total included if he wants to compare it. A remembered household figure and your detailed monthly sheet may cover different things. You don't need to settle that comparison before discussing a specific current expense.

Choose how much you want to share before reopening the sheet. Asking for advice can be voluntary and limited; it doesn't require turning every small purchase into a request for permission.

Isn't narrowing the task another way of avoiding advice you don't want? He may think the whole living arrangement is the problem.

Leave room for a larger suggestion, but ask him to work through its practical costs and trade-offs with you. 'Move somewhere cheaper' can become a discussion of actual options, timing and savings. You can consider that seriously while still making the final decision yourself.

Join the discussion

More in Money