Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I ask a workshop tutor before my unfinished writing is used as a class example?

Education category photographEducation

In our adult writing workshop, we hand in rough pages so the tutor can see what we are working on. Last week she put one of my paragraphs on the screen to demonstrate several problems with dialogue. She removed my name, but it was the scene I had described to the group earlier.

The comments were relevant and nobody was unkind. I still felt caught off guard, and this week I have only submitted the safest, most polished passage I could find. That seems to defeat the point of bringing work in progress.

How can I ask for advance agreement about using my drafts without making it sound as if I only want praise? I am happy to receive criticism; I want to know when it will become a whole-class exercise.

Discussion

5 community replies

Describe the effect in practical terms: you are now choosing safer extracts instead of the work you need help with. That explains why a conversation about how examples are selected would support the workshop's purpose.

You can acknowledge that the dialogue feedback was useful and still say you would like to be asked before a draft is displayed. Those points fit together. Useful criticism does not mean the way it was introduced worked for you.

Ask what the course's normal arrangement is for using submitted work. The tutor may have thought that was understood. It is better to establish a shared expectation now than to keep guessing from one week's activity to the next.

Would advance notice plus an agreed short extract be enough, or would you prefer private feedback on drafts for now? Decide what you are actually asking for before the conversation so the tutor has a concrete request to respond to.

An agreed extract could preserve the group learning if you are comfortable with it. Make clear whether permission is for that passage on that occasion, and how you would like other drafts handled. You do not have to offer blanket permission to prove you can accept criticism.

Join the discussion

More in Education