Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do I apply a fan-group rule when the comment breaking it comes from a close friend?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My friend called another member an idiot for liking the ending. Our group rule says personal insults will be removed. I helped write it.

I removed a similar comment from another member last week. This time I paused because the person posting is someone I also see outside the group. He messaged that I should talk to him privately before doing anything that might embarrass him.

I haven't removed his comment yet. I can understand wanting a private conversation, but the rule doesn't give friends of moderators a different process. Leaving it while I try to protect his feelings already feels like making an exception.

What should I say as I deal with the comment? I'd like to keep the friendship without making other members guess whether the rule depends on who knows the person applying it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the rule you already announced, and explain privately that you're applying the same process used for the earlier comment. You can be direct without making a public example of the friendship.

Keep the film argument separate. Whether you agree with his opinion of the ending doesn't decide whether calling another member an idiot fits the rule.

Acknowledge the hesitation to yourself, then act consistently. You don't need a long confession to the group about your friendship before correcting the uneven treatment.

If you think a warning step would improve the group's process, discuss it as a future rule for everyone rather than inventing it for this one comment.

Yes, a possible policy change shouldn't become a reason to leave this comment under a special arrangement. Deal with the current rule clearly before asking the group whether it wants a different one.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment