Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I answer my son’s questions about periods without sharing his sister’s private details?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old son saw a packet of pads in the shopping and asked what they were for. His grandmother said, ‘That’s girls’ private business,’ and he dropped the subject. Later he asked me whether he was wrong to ask. His fourteen-year-old sister has already told me she does not want family conversations about her own periods.

I want to explain the general facts. The NHS explanation of the menstrual cycle describes a period as blood and the womb lining leaving the body through the vagina. That is information I can discuss without saying anything about his sister’s cycle or symptoms.

I am less sure how to handle his next question, ‘Does my sister have that?’ I do not want to make periods sound shameful, or appoint her as the household demonstration. How do I keep an ordinary conversation open while respecting the privacy she specifically asked for?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him the question about the pads was welcome. You can explain their general purpose yourself, using the NHS information, without waiting for his sister to agree to be involved in the conversation.

‘I can explain periods, but I don’t share other people’s body information’ is a usable answer to the sister question. It gives a reason for the boundary without suggesting that the subject itself is forbidden.

Have a separate, quiet word with his grandmother about the wording. Ask her to direct these questions to you if she would rather not answer. Your son does not need to watch a family argument to find out that asking was acceptable.

Check that protecting his sister does not become repeatedly announcing that she has a special secret. A short privacy answer, followed by asking what he wants to understand, may keep the discussion on the general topic he raised.

That is a helpful distinction. He might simply want to know what the shopping is for. Answering that question need not expand into an account of his sister’s experiences, or an explanation of why she prefers not to discuss them.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting