Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How can my teacher-training notes distinguish what I saw from what I inferred?

Education category photographEducation

In my classroom observation notes, I wrote that a pupil was not interested in the task. Reading the notes later, I realised I had recorded a conclusion as though I had directly seen it.

What I actually saw was that the pupil copied the heading, looked towards the window during instructions and left the next section blank while others began. I did not hear a conversation with the pupil or know whether they understood the task.

The observation assignment asks for analysis, so I cannot solve this by listing actions with no thought about them. How should I separate description, possible explanations and questions for my mentor? I want the notes to help me learn about teaching without turning one short observation into a judgement about the pupil.

Discussion

5 community replies

Replace the claim about interest with the actions and sequence you actually observed. Keep any interpretation in a separate part of the note, using language that makes its tentative status clear.

Ask what evidence would help distinguish possible explanations. For example, knowing whether the pupil could explain the instruction would answer a different question from simply seeing that the page was blank. Treat that as a question to discuss with the teacher, not a diagnosis to make yourself.

Analysis could focus on the teaching too: how instructions were given, what checks of understanding you observed and what help was available. That gives you something to examine without requiring you to decide what the pupil was thinking.

Your mentor may have relevant context from other lessons. Ask which parts of your account they recognise and what else they would consider. Keep clear which information comes from that discussion and which comes from your own observation.

If the mentor supplies context, attribute it in the way your placement expects rather than rewriting it as something you witnessed. You can explain how it changes your interpretation while preserving the limits of the short episode you actually saw.

Join the discussion

More in Education