Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How can my child write about an act of kindness without revealing another family's private situation?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old wants to write about giving an outgrown school coat to another child for a class kindness display. The receiving family had asked us to keep the arrangement private. My son wants to name the child so the teacher knows his account is specific.

The assignment asks for a short example of kindness; it does not ask for a recipient's name or a photograph. I originally encouraged him to include details, then realised which details he meant.

He is pleased he helped and says removing the name will make it sound as though he is hiding something. I want him to know that recognising his own contribution does not mean everyone else's circumstances become material for a classroom display.

How would you explain that distinction? I am also unsure whether leaving out the name is enough when classmates might recognise the coat or the situation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him the promise of privacy was about the other family's information, not about being ashamed of helping. The teacher can understand an act of kindness without knowing which child needed the coat.

Removing a name may not be enough if the remaining details identify the family. Since this is for a class display, choosing another example could be more respectful than trying to disguise a story classmates can easily recognise.

If he is worried the work will not count, ask the teacher about the assignment in general terms. Do not explain the receiving family's circumstances while asking whether your son is allowed to keep them private.

He can still be proud of what he did without receiving public credit for that particular act. Offer to talk about the experience privately, while helping him choose a display example that does not rely on someone else's personal situation.

That leaves room for both the pride and the promise. A different example need not be grand: helping organise a shared activity or doing a practical job could fit, depending on the brief. Do not invent an impressive substitute; help him describe something he actually did and can appropriately share.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting