Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How can I make a class diagram readable when colour carries all the labels?

Education category photographEducation

Our group is making an online science explainer. In one diagram, red circles mean particle type A and green circles mean type B. The legend names the types, but the circles themselves have no letters, numbers or other differences.

A classmate could not reliably tell which was which. One teammate wants to use brighter colours and says adding labels will spoil the clean design. I am unsure that changing the palette would solve the actual problem.

W3C's explanation of its Use of Color criterion describes providing another visible way to understand information conveyed by colour. What would be a useful revision to our diagram that keeps it clear without depending on the reader distinguishing those two colours?

Discussion

5 community replies

Put the identity on the items themselves, for example A and B inside the relevant circles, with a matching legend. The reader would then have a way to identify each type even when the colours are difficult to distinguish.

Check the connections as well as the circles. If different kinds of line also have meaning only through colour, consider consistent labels, line styles or other visible distinctions there too. Fixing one part should not leave the rest of the explanation dependent on the same problem.

You do not have to remove colour. W3C's guidance allows colour to contribute when another visible cue carries the meaning as well. Try a labelled version alongside the current one and discuss whether it still communicates the scientific relationships clearly.

A monochrome view could be a useful check of whether you are still relying on hue. It would not, by itself, prove that the whole online explainer meets accessibility requirements or works for every reader.

Use that check to ask whether type A and type B remain identifiable, then review the diagram at its intended display size. Labels that exist but cannot be read would need attention too. Adding labels addresses one problem; the image still needs an appropriate text alternative and the wider explainer needs its own accessibility review.

Join the discussion

More in Education