Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How can I ask a teacher to stop comparing my work with my older sibling's?

Education category photographEducation

“Your brother always enjoyed this sort of essay,” the teacher said. I had asked about the comment on my own paragraph.

She taught him a few years ago and remembers him warmly. I liked that connection at first. Now my work and subject choices often lead back to what he did. When I say I am interested in a different option, she reminds me how well he got on with his.

I don't have evidence that the marking is unfair, and I don't want to turn a familiar comment into that accusation. I do want feedback and advice that start from the work and interests I bring, rather than a family comparison I cannot answer.

What could I say after class? My brother has done nothing wrong, and I don't want to criticise him just to establish that I am a different pupil.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say that you appreciate her remembering your brother, then ask to focus feedback on your paragraph and what you should do next. You can describe the effect of the comparisons without judging the relationship she had with him.

Use one or two actual examples rather than 'you always compare us.' That gives the teacher something recognisable to respond to and keeps the conversation from becoming a debate about every family reference.

You do not need to prove that your brother struggled somewhere or that your choices are better. Different interests are enough reason to ask for advice about your own options.

Keep the marking concern separate unless you have specific evidence for it. You can ask for comments tied to the criteria now, and use the school's normal route if an actual assessment discrepancy later needs checking.

Criteria-based feedback may also help you redirect a comparison in the moment: 'What does that mean for this part of my work?' If the pattern continues after a clear request, ask a trusted staff member to help you have the conversation.

Join the discussion

More in Education