Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Half our table is new to the board game. Should we really add the expansion on their first night?

Gaming category photographGaming

The host put the expansion beside the base game and said it would keep things interesting for the regulars. Two friends were still learning what the base game's turn involved.

I know both versions. The expansion adds another resource and changes the opening choices. I can see why the people who have played often want something fresh. I can also see the newcomers trying to remember which of the things we've explained they need right now.

The host owns everything and has prepared it. Nobody is being asked for another purchase. The question is what kind of first session we are offering, especially when the invitation said we'd teach the game.

Would you start with the base version, offer a short demonstration of the extra system, or pick something else that is new to everyone? I want the regulars to enjoy the evening too, without treating the first game as preparation the newcomers must endure before reaching our preferred version.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the new players what they understood the invitation to involve and explain the choice briefly. They should be able to express a preference without first mastering the expansion well enough to judge all its interactions.

Owning and preparing the expansion is a contribution, but it doesn't settle whether it fits this table tonight. Acknowledge the host's effort while discussing the experience you want everyone to have.

One base-game session could give the newcomers a clearer reference for the expansion later. Offer that as a plan if the regulars are willing, rather than claiming it is the only correct way anyone can learn.

If the regulars don't want another base-game evening, choose a different shared game instead of turning the newcomers' first attempt into the price of admission. A fresh choice for everyone may be more honest about what the group wants.

Check that the alternative is actually manageable in the time available. 'New to everyone' doesn't automatically mean simple to start. The useful change is an invitation matched to the people and the evening, not a different box with the same unexplained burden.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming