Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

For tomato canning, does any bottle of lemon juice count as the bottled juice in the recipe?

Food category photographFood

I'm following an NCHFP tomato-canning method and bought a bottle of lemon juice labelled not from concentrate. I thought bottled described the container, and my sister prefers that product's flavour. We haven't filled any jars.

NCHFP's guidance on the type of bottled lemon juice says to use bottled juice made from concentrate for canning and explains that its tested recipes were developed with that product. The bottle I chose doesn't match that instruction.

I'm getting the appropriate ingredient and following the complete current tested method. How would you organise the shopping check so this doesn't become an argument at the filling stage about which juice tastes fresher? I want the ingredient requirement settled before we begin.

Discussion

5 community replies

Put made from concentrate on the shopping note, alongside the full ingredient specification in the tested method. Bottled alone didn't tell you enough for this use.

Read the actual label together before starting. Your sister's flavour preference can be real without establishing that the other product fits the canning instructions.

Keep the complete tested procedure available too. Getting the juice right doesn't replace the requirements for the tomatoes, packing, processing and elevation in that method.

Could you choose a tested tomato method that explicitly permits citric acid instead, if the lemon flavour is the sticking point?

Yes, use that option only as the tested method specifies, with its stated quantity and process. NCHFP distinguishes permitted alternatives from casually swapping acids across recipes. Don't turn an option for one tomato method into a general substitution for other preserves.

Join the discussion

More in Food