Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Every playtester seems to want a different board game. How do I choose which feedback to act on?

Gaming category photographGaming

One friend's note asked for more surprises. Another wanted fewer event cards so plans would matter more. I changed the deck after each conversation and ended up unsure what I wanted the game to be.

This is a hobby prototype about planning deliveries together. I like a little uncertainty, but the main idea was cooperating on a route. Both friends have useful observations; their preferred experiences aren't identical.

There is also a confusing turn-order instruction that I watched both of them struggle with. Fixing that feels different from deciding how much surprise the game should contain, yet I've put everything on the same list of things I owe the next version.

What would you decide before another playtest? I'd like to ask clearer questions, act on problems that matter and keep a direction for the game, without treating a friend's suggestion as either a command or something to defend myself against.

Discussion

5 community replies

Write a short description of the experience you want the game to offer before changing the deck again. Planning together with some uncertainty is a direction you can test. It won't require every player to prefer the same balance.

Ask each friend which moment led to the request. 'More surprises' might mean a predictable ending, while 'fewer events' might reflect a plan being overturned without a useful response. The underlying observation may help more than adopting either requested feature immediately.

Keep the confusing turn-order instruction distinct from the preference questions. You have a concrete problem people encountered while trying to follow the game. Fixing the explanation doesn't require deciding the entire design at once.

Choose one design question for the next version and explain what you want to learn from the test. Avoid changing every major system and then trying to attribute the reaction to one altered deck.

If the change pleases one person and weakens the experience you intended, use that information when deciding what to keep. You can thank a friend for useful feedback without making the prototype a promise to build their favorite game.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming