Every playtester seems to want a different board game. How do I choose which feedback to act on?
GamingOne friend's note asked for more surprises. Another wanted fewer event cards so plans would matter more. I changed the deck after each conversation and ended up unsure what I wanted the game to be.
This is a hobby prototype about planning deliveries together. I like a little uncertainty, but the main idea was cooperating on a route. Both friends have useful observations; their preferred experiences aren't identical.
There is also a confusing turn-order instruction that I watched both of them struggle with. Fixing that feels different from deciding how much surprise the game should contain, yet I've put everything on the same list of things I owe the next version.
What would you decide before another playtest? I'd like to ask clearer questions, act on problems that matter and keep a direction for the game, without treating a friend's suggestion as either a command or something to defend myself against.