Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Does 'winner picks the next game' include one we don't have time to finish?

Gaming category photographGaming

Our friendly rule is that the winner picks the next board game. This time the winner chose a game we usually give a whole evening, when we had about an hour left before several people needed to leave.

They rarely win and were pleased to finally choose. Saying no felt as though the reward only counted when they picked what the rest of us already wanted. Starting would also mean knowing that some players couldn't stay for the game we'd just agreed to play.

How do we honour the choice without treating the time left as imaginary? We never said what limits came with the reward.

Discussion

5 community replies

Recognise the choice and the missing condition separately. You can say that this is the game they get to choose while explaining that tonight's remaining time won't support the way the group normally plays it.

Ask whether they would prefer a shorter choice now or a concrete plan to play this one another evening. Don't promise a future session on behalf of people who haven't agreed to attend.

The winner's frustration makes sense if the limits only became visible after their turn to choose. Acknowledge that instead of insisting the rule was always perfectly clear.

For future nights, define the eligible choices before the game whose winner receives the reward. Time, attendance and an actual available copy can be ordinary conditions everyone knows in advance.

And apply those conditions when a regular winner chooses too. Otherwise the clearer rule still feels like an exception invented for the person who finally got a turn.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming