Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Does voting on every holiday activity stay fair when the same friend always loses?

Travel category photographTravel

The botanical garden loses four votes to one. Noor closes the leaflet. It is the fourth afternoon choice on the trip, and none of hers has won.

Five friends agreed before travelling that they would choose activities by majority vote. Noor thought that sounded fair. The others have similar tastes, while her suggestions have tended towards gardens and quieter walks. She has joined their winning plans and tried to enjoy them.

With two afternoons left, she asks whether they could sometimes take turns choosing instead. Felix says changing the system now would ignore what four people want because one person is disappointed. Another friend says Noor can visit the garden alone.

Noor could do that, but part of why she booked a group holiday was to share things she enjoys with these friends. She also does not want their willingness to visit a garden to become a test of whether they care about her. What could a fair adjustment look like when the original arrangement is working well for most of the group?

Discussion

5 community replies

They could give Noor one of the remaining afternoons to propose within an agreed budget and timetable, while keeping room for anyone to say an activity really does not work for them. Taking turns choosing need not mean one person gets unlimited control.

Felix is right that they agreed on voting. It is still reasonable to revisit an arrangement after seeing what it produces. Noor should say that she initially expected a more varied result, rather than claim the others broke an agreement.

The suggestion to go alone answers how Noor can see the garden, but not her wish to share something she likes. She could explain that difference without insisting all four friends accompany her.

One interested companion could make the garden visit a shared afternoon without turning the next vote into a friendship referendum. Noor could ask who would enjoy joining her, while the others choose their own activity.

That could be a good option if someone genuinely wants to come. They can agree when to meet afterwards and let both outings count as part of the holiday. Noor should not have to spend the garden visit reassuring a reluctant companion who feels sent there as a duty.

Join the discussion

More in Travel