Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does replacing my child's cash make it all right that I borrowed it without asking?

Parenting category photographParenting

I used coins from my twelve-year-old's savings jar when I needed cash for parking, then put the same amount back that evening. When I mentioned it, he asked why I hadn't asked him first. I said he hadn't lost anything.

He replied that if he took money from my purse and returned it later, I wouldn't call that fine. My partner thinks this is a small practical favour within a family, provided the money is replaced. I had treated its being available in the kitchen as though that settled whether I could use it.

The CFPB's guidance for parents of school-age children and preteens encourages adults to explain their day-to-day money choices rather than leave children to draw conclusions from the action alone. My explanation so far has been that being repaid means he has no reason to mind.

What would you say now? I want us to be willing to help each other without turning his savings into a cash supply he didn't agree to provide.

Discussion

5 community replies

Repayment answers whether the money is back. His question is why you treated asking as optional. You can acknowledge that difference without making this a speech about financial crime: "I should have asked. Replacing it didn't make that choice yours."

The comparison with your purse is worth answering directly. If the family rule is to ask before using someone else's cash, follow it yourself. Explaining why you needed coins can give context, but it doesn't by itself establish that he'd agreed to lend them.

I can see your partner's wish for ordinary family generosity. Asking can be part of that generosity, though. A loan he willingly agrees to is a different family interaction from discovering afterward that the adults have already used the jar.

If you ask next time, what happens if he says no? Decide that before offering an apology built around permission. If refusing would bring a lecture about selfishness, he wouldn't have much of a choice.

Exactly. You can say you'd appreciate help and still arrange another way to pay if he declines. There is no need for an expensive apology gift; a clear change in what you do with the jar would address the concern he actually raised.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting