Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Does our umbrella policy let us reduce the rebuilding cover on our home?

Housing category photographHousing

At renewal, my partner put our US homeowners policy and umbrella policy side by side and added their limits together. The combined number looked reassuring. Now they want to reduce the dwelling cover to bring down the premium, on the assumption that the umbrella would help if rebuilding exceeded it.

I found the Texas Department of Insurance's explanation of umbrella insurance as additional liability coverage. I think we may be adding limits that cover different things. My partner says that if the umbrella protects our assets, surely our own house is included.

I do want to question the renewal price. I just do not want an apparent saving based on a misunderstanding. What should we ask the agent to explain before changing either policy, and how can we compare the answers without trying to choose a rebuilding limit from a headline insurance figure?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the agent to walk through two distinct examples using your documents: covered damage to your own building, and a covered liability claim against you. Which section responds in each, what limits and deductibles apply, and when would the umbrella respond? Request the explanation in writing so both of you can revisit it.

Keep the premium question on the table. You can request alternatives and a review of the information used to assess reconstruction costs without deciding in advance that dwelling cover must fall. Ask the insurer to explain the trade-offs of each proposed change and any underlying coverage requirements for your umbrella.

The phrase 'protects our assets' seems to be causing the confusion. It can describe protection against a claim you owe someone else; it does not establish that an insurer pays to rebuild each asset you own. I would ask the agent to explain that phrase against the policy wording.

That explanation would address the actual misunderstanding. Your partner may be trying to avoid paying twice for the same thing. Seeing which loss each policy responds to gives you a way to ask whether cover overlaps, rather than assuming that the two large numbers are interchangeable.

Join the discussion

More in Housing