Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does my son's swimming badge change our rule about life jackets on a boat?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old has just passed a swimming badge and is proud of the distance he can swim. We're planning to hire a rowing boat on holiday. When I mentioned life jackets, he said, "But I've passed now. You said those were for people who can't swim."

I did say that on an earlier trip. Worse, I wore mine for the first few minutes and then took it off. My partner thinks insisting now will sound as though we don't believe the badge means anything. Our son wants us to watch him swim before deciding.

The US Coast Guard's guidance recommends wearing an appropriate life jacket while a boat is underway. It explains that flotation can help when someone is unexpectedly in the water or cannot keep themselves afloat through fatigue, injury or cold. Swimming ability doesn't settle those situations.

I want everyone in our boat wearing suitable, properly fitted equipment. How do I correct what I told him without turning his achievement into another test he has failed?

Discussion

5 community replies

The badge can mean exactly what it says: he has learned particular swimming skills. You can celebrate those skills and still say, "I explained the jacket badly. It isn't something you graduate out of by passing a swimming test." He doesn't need to demonstrate his distance again.

Your own jacket is the part you can change immediately. Tell him before the outing that you will wear yours throughout, too. Otherwise he has a reasonable question about why your confidence counts as an exemption and his confidence doesn't.

I wouldn't make a demonstration swim the price of having this discussion. That accepts his idea that one more display of ability might earn the exemption. Ask the hire staff about suitable equipment and the outing's safety requirements before committing to the trip.

Check whether he also dislikes the feel of the jacket. Being proud of his swimming and finding a particular jacket uncomfortable could both be true. Ask the hire staff to check the fit and activity suitability rather than treating every complaint as an argument about the badge.

That gives him something useful to influence: tell the staff where it rubs and try an appropriate alternative if available. It doesn't mean loosening the straps or accepting an oversized jacket to end the disagreement. If suitable equipment isn't available, the boat plan needs to change.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting