Does my dishonest protagonist need to be punished so readers know I disagree with him?
EntertainmentIn a short story I'm revising, a man lies about a colleague's contribution and gets the promotion he wanted. The final scene is a cheerful office toast. I meant the ending to feel uncomfortable: the workplace rewards him, and he accepts the congratulations.
My beta reader thought the story admired him for being clever. She says that if he gets away with it, I need to add a consequence so readers know I don't approve. I explained my intention, but she said she could only respond to the story on the page.
I don't want to add a last-minute punishment just to demonstrate that lying is wrong. I also can't dismiss her reading when the unease I intended hasn't reached her. What should I look at in the ending before deciding whether the problem is the outcome or the way I've written it?