Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Does my dishonest protagonist need to be punished so readers know I disagree with him?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

In a short story I'm revising, a man lies about a colleague's contribution and gets the promotion he wanted. The final scene is a cheerful office toast. I meant the ending to feel uncomfortable: the workplace rewards him, and he accepts the congratulations.

My beta reader thought the story admired him for being clever. She says that if he gets away with it, I need to add a consequence so readers know I don't approve. I explained my intention, but she said she could only respond to the story on the page.

I don't want to add a last-minute punishment just to demonstrate that lying is wrong. I also can't dismiss her reading when the unease I intended hasn't reached her. What should I look at in the ending before deciding whether the problem is the outcome or the way I've written it?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask her which details made the toast feel admiring. Was it the narrator's wording, the protagonist's pleasure, or the absence of any attention to the colleague? You need evidence from the scene before deciding that changing who gets promoted is the useful revision.

An unpunished character leaves you several possible effects: admiration, frustration, dread, bleak comedy. Keeping the promotion doesn't settle which of those your ending creates. Look at what the final paragraphs invite the reader to notice and enjoy.

Don't turn the next draft into a hidden test where a reader has to detect your disapproval to pass. You can invite a fresh reader to describe their impression of the ending without first explaining what they are meant to feel. Their reading would give you another response to consider, rather than a verdict by vote.

Your beta reader's interpretation is valuable; her proposed punishment is one possible repair. You can take the interpretation seriously while trying a different revision. For example, the same toast might land differently if the scene makes the colleague's exclusion visible without an explanatory speech.

That example preserves the outcome while changing where the attention falls. It could also become heavy-handed if every detail underlines the lesson. Try the smallest change that expresses what matters to you, then read the whole ending for tone rather than checking only whether the new clue is present.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment