Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does knocking count if I open my child's bedroom door before she answers?

Parenting category photographParenting

My twelve-year-old put a "Please knock" note on her bedroom door. Yesterday I knocked while pushing it open with a basket of clean clothes. She was changing and called out for me to wait. I said, "I did knock," and carried on putting the clothes away.

Later she asked what the point of knocking was if I was already coming in. My partner says knocking has always meant announcing ourselves in our house, so she needs to explain if she wants something different. I think her request was fairly clear, even if I didn't stop to consider it.

There wasn't an urgent concern; I was delivering laundry. On the other hand, I don't want to stand outside with a heavy basket waiting indefinitely, and I would welcome her taking over more of putting her clothes away.

What should we agree about closed doors and waiting for an answer? I want an ordinary privacy arrangement that works in daily life, rather than making her explain exactly what she is doing each time she wants a minute.

Discussion

5 community replies

In this instance she did say wait, and you continued. I'd acknowledge that directly before discussing the household meaning of knocking. "You asked me to wait while you changed. I should have stopped and closed the door" answers the incident she actually raised.

The basket doesn't have to wait for bedroom access. You could agree that clean clothes go on the landing and she collects and puts them away. That gives her a clear share of the work and removes a routine reason for you to enter with your hands full.

Agree the practice with the whole household, including siblings. A note on her door shouldn't leave her negotiating separately with each person about whether a knock means notice or a request to come in.

She shouldn't need to announce that she is changing to get an ordinary request for a minute accepted. "Hang on" can be enough information. You can also ask her to answer a knock when she hears it, so nobody is left guessing whether she is there.

Yes, the arrangement can include an answer without requiring an explanation. If laundry isn't urgent and she doesn't reply, leave the basket in the agreed place and ask later. That solves this routine delivery without making every quiet moment behind a closed door a dispute.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting