Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does independence mean my child has to make every small choice herself?

Parenting category photographParenting

At breakfast I asked my seven-year-old to choose cereal or toast. She said, "Can you just make one today?" I told her she needed to choose for herself so she'd learn to be independent.

My partner asked why choosing to let me decide didn't count. I hadn't thought of that. I offer choices over clothes, breakfast and what to pack for the afternoon, because I don't want to make every decision for her. Lately I seem to be insisting on an answer even when she says neither option matters much.

I don't want to take over the decisions she does care about. I also don't want an ordinary breakfast to become a test she has to pass before anyone puts food on the table. She is happy to make some choices and asks for help with others.

Where would you draw the line? I'd like a practical way to offer a say without making the offer itself another demand.

Discussion

5 community replies

Cereal or toast doesn't have to be the morning's independence examination. You can accept, "You choose today," when you're willing to make the choice. That doesn't require you to stop asking about things she does care about.

An announced default might help: "I'm making toast; tell me if you'd rather have cereal." She still has a say, but breakfast doesn't stop until she supplies an answer. Use an option you're actually prepared to provide.

Ask which choices she likes having. Perhaps clothes matter to her and breakfast doesn't, or it changes from one morning to another. You don't need a general verdict that she either can or can't decide for herself.

What worries you about choosing when she asks? If it's that she'll dislike your choice afterward, agree what you can reasonably change once breakfast is made. That is a concrete issue to discuss, separate from whether she is independent enough.

And handing the decision back needn't promise unlimited replacement breakfasts. You can make the requested choice, explain what's available and still let her say she would prefer something else next time. A preference after the fact isn't proof that she failed the original choice.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting