Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Does Grade A on an egg carton mean the eggs are the large size my cake recipe expects?

Food category photographFood

I'm using a US cake recipe that calls for large eggs. The carton I bought in the US says Grade A and medium. I'd noticed the grade first and nearly treated it as confirmation that I'd bought the standard eggs the recipe meant.

USDA's explanation of shell-egg grades distinguishes quality grade from weight or size and notes that eggs of a given grade can differ in weight.

How would you handle this before mixing? I can use appropriate recipe-author guidance for a size substitution or get the specified size, but I don't want a quality label to do a measurement job it doesn't answer.

Discussion

5 community replies

Read grade and size as separate information. USDA's explanation doesn't make Grade A another way of saying large.

If the recipe provides an egg weight, check how its author wants that measured. Don't invent a replacement count from the quality grade.

The medium eggs can have a suitable use without being the exact size this cake specifies. Getting the size wrong for one formula doesn't require treating the whole purchase as worthless.

I'd get large eggs for the first cake attempt and plan another meal with the medium ones.

That prioritises the original formula without making a judgment that smaller eggs are a lower quality grade. The two labels answer different questions.

Join the discussion

More in Food