Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Does clear mountain-stream water mean we can refill our walking bottles untreated?

Travel category photographTravel

The route crosses several streams, so Tom suggests carrying less water. “You can see straight through it in the photographs,” he tells Aisha.

They are preparing a day walk during their holiday. Neither has checked for reliable drinking-water points or arranged an appropriate treatment method. Tom has assumed that remote, clear-looking water will be suitable to drink as it is.

The CDC's outdoor-water guidance says water containing harmful germs can look clean, and drinking directly from a clear mountain stream is generally unsafe. Appearance is not a way to establish potability.

What should they change before setting out? Aisha wants a realistic plan for enough safe drinking water, including any refill arrangements they actually verify. They can adjust the walk or prepare properly rather than make a photograph of a stream do the work of a water plan.

Discussion

5 community replies

Do not plan to drink the stream water untreated because it looks clear. The CDC guidance specifically warns that harmful germs can be present in apparently clean water.

Verify any proposed drinking-water points for this walk before relying on them. A stream on a map is not the same as a confirmed source of safe drinking water.

If they intend to treat water, use authoritative guidance and suitable products as instructed. They should establish that method before departure rather than improvise from whatever happens to be in the bag.

Would a different walk make their water arrangements more manageable? That could be a sensible planning choice while they are still at the accommodation.

They can compare routes using the supplies and reliable information they have. Choosing a workable day out now would be more useful than leaving Aisha to object later, once the bottles are low and Tom is already committed to a stream refill.

Join the discussion

More in Travel