Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Does being posted on arXiv make a paper peer reviewed for my assignment?

Education category photographEducation

My essay brief asks for peer-reviewed research. I found a paper on arXiv that fits my question, and I have read it closely. I described it as peer reviewed in my draft because I assumed that a research repository checked papers in that way before posting them.

arXiv's own moderation guidance explicitly distinguishes moderation from peer review. I have not yet established whether this particular paper also has a journal or conference publication.

What should I check before deciding whether it meets the brief? I do not want to discard useful reading, but I also cannot count a process I merely assumed had happened.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the description in your draft now. Posting on arXiv is not evidence that arXiv carried out peer review. That does not, by itself, establish whether the work has been reviewed elsewhere.

Look for a linked journal or conference publication, then verify the matching work and its publication status at that venue. A similar title alone should not be the end of the check.

Take the actual paper and the assignment wording to the tutor if its eligibility remains unclear. Useful background reading and a source that satisfies a specified requirement can be different things.

If you locate a published version, read it before switching your citation. Check whether the argument, results or qualifications you used are still there rather than treating the new reference as a replacement label.

That comparison can affect your essay as well as the bibliography. If the published version changes the passage you relied on, revise the claim to match the version you actually read and cite. Do not assume that locating a publication settles every point you took from the earlier file.

Join the discussion

More in Education