Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Does an ordinary reserved Shinkansen seat include space for a large suitcase?

Travel category photographTravel

“There's a gap behind the back row,” Oliver says. His friend Diana checks their tickets: their seats are in the middle of an ordinary car.

They are due to take the Tokaido Shinkansen from Tokyo to Kyoto. Diana's suitcase has combined length, width and height of 168 cm. They booked reserved seats without selecting an oversized-baggage arrangement.

JR Central's current guidance says passengers bringing baggage over 160 cm in combined dimensions on this route need a seat with an oversized-baggage area. The space behind the relevant seats is for passengers who reserved it; an ordinary seat reservation is not the same thing.

Oliver wants to board and use whatever space looks empty. Diana would rather resolve the reservation before travelling. She needs the case for a longer trip and does not want the answer reduced to being told she packed too much.

What should they ask the operator while they can still change the plan? Their luggage arrangement needs to fit the actual train and booking, rather than depend on another passenger's reserved space appearing unused.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check whether their booking can be changed to the appropriate seat with an oversized-baggage area before departure. JR Central explains the requirement. They should not board assuming that any reserved seat covers Diana's 168 cm case.

An empty-looking gap is not evidence that nobody has reserved its use. Oliver's plan would leave the luggage problem to be resolved on board. Their confirmed reservation should specify the arrangement they actually need.

Check the current instructions for this route and ticket rather than apply a luggage rule from another Japanese train. They should also distinguish a general storage area from the reservation required for baggage in Diana's size category.

Diana may reasonably want to keep the case for the rest of the trip. The first task is to establish whether the appropriate reservation is available, not decide that her whole packing choice was foolish.

If they cannot arrange suitable space on the intended departure, they can ask about actual alternatives and their terms. A different departure or a different packing arrangement would need confirming; neither should be promised before they know what is possible.

Join the discussion

More in Travel