Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does accepting an apology mean my child has to lend the same treasured thing again?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old lent a friend a model spaceship. The friend returned it with a broken wing, apologised and helped put it back together. My son said he forgave him. A week later the friend asked to borrow it again, and my son said no.

I told him he could not keep holding it against someone after accepting an apology. He said he was not angry and still wanted the friend to come over. He just did not want that particular model leaving the house again.

I want him to allow people to make mistakes without keeping a permanent account of them. I also cannot quite explain why forgiveness should require another loan of the same fragile thing. Would you encourage a second chance here, suggest something they could use together or leave the borrowing decision with him? I do not want the friend’s apology to become a bargain neither child actually agreed to.

Discussion

5 community replies

He has already described a limited boundary: the model stays home, and the friendship continues. That is different from refusing to speak to the friend or repeatedly bringing up the broken wing. Respond to the limit he actually set.

The friend’s apology and help with the repair still mattered. You can recognise that without treating them as payment for another loan. An apology can address what happened without deciding every future request.

Ask your son whether he would like help saying no kindly. He does not need to make a new accusation: ‘I’m keeping this model at home now’ explains the decision. Avoid promising the friend a substitute belonging on his behalf.

A second chance could be spending time together, not repeating the exact borrowing arrangement. But I would offer that as a distinction for the parent to consider, rather than require the son to arrange a demonstration that he has forgiven properly.

Agreed. He has already said he wants his friend to visit. There is no need to make shared play another proof he must provide. The useful repair for the parent is to withdraw the claim that forgiveness obliges him to lend the spaceship.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting