Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Does a thank-you phone call count when I wanted my child to write a card?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old phoned his aunt to thank her for a scarf she'd knitted. He put it on during the call, told her he liked the colours and chatted with her for a while. Afterward I asked him to write a card as well.

He said he'd already thanked her. I replied that a proper thank-you had to be written. My partner pointed out that his aunt had sounded pleased, and that I was treating a conversation she'd enjoyed as though it hadn't happened.

I like handwritten cards because people can keep them, especially after the work of making a gift. His aunt hasn't asked for one. I can ask him to make something for her, but I'm unsure whether that is an additional kind gesture or part of acknowledging the scarf that he still owes.

How would you explain the value of a card without telling him his spoken thanks didn't count? I want him to consider the person receiving it, rather than finish a task simply so I can mark his manners as satisfactory.

Discussion

5 community replies

Recognise the call before asking for more. He named something he liked and spent time talking to the person who made the scarf. You can say that was a thoughtful thank-you even if you would also enjoy sending her a keepsake.

I'd change the wording from "a proper thank-you" to your actual reason: "Auntie might like a note she can keep." Then consider a short note or drawing rather than assuming the only acceptable format is the formal card you pictured.

Making a gift doesn't automatically tell you which response its maker prefers. His aunt may value conversation more than a card. You could find out what she enjoys without asking her to settle an argument about whether your son has been polite enough.

Could the two of you send something together? You could write your own appreciation for the time she put into the scarf, and invite him to add a line or drawing. That would let you express your value for the handmade gift without making him responsible for conveying all of it.

That seems fair, provided your part isn't framed as repairing his inadequate thanks. He already made his own contribution in the call. A family note can add something different, and your gratitude for her work can genuinely be yours to express.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting