Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does a proposed US constitutional amendment need the president’s signature?

Politics category photographPolitics

I said a US president could refuse to sign a proposed constitutional amendment just as they could veto an ordinary bill. A friend pointed me to the amendment process, and I could see I had carried the legislative analogy too far.

The National Archives’ explanation of constitutional amendments says the president has no constitutional role in that process: a congressional resolution proposing an amendment does not go to the White House for signature or approval. Proposal and ratification follow Article V instead.

How can I correct that distinction without suggesting the president cannot have a political opinion about an amendment? We are discussing the process, not the status or merits of any particular proposed amendment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say exactly what you got wrong: presidential signature or veto is not a step in the Article V amendment process. There’s no need to defend the original analogy once that difference is clear.

Keep proposal and ratification distinct too. A proposal from Congress is not, by that action alone, a completed change to the Constitution.

Use a separate process diagram if the group is comparing ordinary legislation and amendments. Reusing the bill diagram with one label changed may leave other assumptions in place.

A president could publicly support an amendment and encourage people to back it. Wouldn’t that still be a role?

It would be political involvement, rather than the constitutional approval step you originally described. You can discuss that influence while stating that the amendment resolution does not require a presidential signature.

Join the discussion

More in Politics

Explore Politics discussions →