Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Does a picture of a signature prove a PDF hasn't changed?

Technology category photographTechnology

A colleague pointed to the signature image at the bottom of a PDF design approval and said that proved the file was unchanged. I haven't checked whether the file contains a certificate-based digital signature or only the visible mark.

Adobe describes validating digital signatures by reviewing the signature status and certificate information. Adobe's validation guidance

What evidence should I check about this particular revision? I don't want to confuse what a page looks like with a technical check of its signed content, or assume that an image tells me which kind of signature is present.

Discussion

5 community replies

Inspect the file's signature information rather than decide from the visible mark. Adobe's validation workflow concerns a digital signature, its certificate and signed content. A signature-shaped image alone doesn't establish those properties. Validate signatures

If a digital signature is present, read the validation details and certificate information, including any warnings. Adobe describes those checks; don't add an unfamiliar certificate to a trusted list simply to make an inconvenient status look satisfactory. Validation details

The picture doesn't prove the opposite either. A visible mark may accompany a digital signature, so don't announce that the PDF is unsigned just because it includes handwriting. Check what the actual file reports.

Confirm through the established sender which revision was approved and how that approval was recorded. That can help resolve the working-document question if the technical feature you expected isn't present.

Keep the conclusions separate when reporting back. A missing certificate-based signature doesn't by itself prove that nobody approved the design, while a visible approval mark doesn't establish an integrity check. State which evidence you have instead of turning either observation into an accusation or a guarantee.

Join the discussion

More in Technology