Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Does a matching checksum prove that a download from a forum is authentic?

Technology category photographTechnology

A forum post linked to an Ubuntu installation image and showed a checksum. The checksum I calculated matched the one in the post, so I told a friend the download was verified.

She asked where the comparison value came from. Both the link and the screenshot came from the same poster. Ubuntu's verification guidance distinguishes authenticating the signed checksum information from checking the image against it. Ubuntu image verification

I haven't used the image yet. What should I establish before trusting it? I can see that I checked a match without establishing who supplied the reference I trusted.

Discussion

5 community replies

Go to Ubuntu's official verification instructions and establish a trusted source for the signed checksums. Comparing a file with a number supplied by the same unverified forum post doesn't authenticate that post's claim. Ubuntu documents the signature and image-hash checks as separate parts of verification. Official guidance

Correct the explanation to your friend: you established a match to the posted value, not the origin of that value. That is useful precision, rather than a reason to pretend the calculation itself was pointless.

A checksum match also isn't a general promise that software is suitable for every computer or free of every defect. Keep the claim tied to the file and reference you actually checked. Don't turn “matches the authenticated release” into “nothing can go wrong.”

Keep track of the exact image file, release and official verification material used. That would make it possible to explain what you checked instead of relying on a screenshot saying “passed.”

If you later replace the image with another download, check that file too. A result attached only to an earlier filename isn't evidence about whichever copy happens to be selected next. The record should identify the actual artifact, not just the intention to verify one.

Join the discussion

More in Technology