Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Does a low avalanche rating make an unfamiliar off-piste route suitable for our holiday group?

Travel category photographTravel

The forecast tile is green. “Low danger,” Callum says. “That settles the route.”

Their winter holiday group has been skiing marked runs and is discussing a trip into unfamiliar, unpatrolled terrain in North America. They have not established whether they have the training, local knowledge and appropriate arrangements for that route. Callum has read the headline rating but not the full bulletin.

Avalanche.org's explanation of Level 1 says natural and human-triggered avalanches are unlikely, but avalanches can still be triggered on isolated features and in extreme terrain. The lowest rating is not an individual route assessment or a measure of this group's preparedness.

How should they decide what to do instead of treating the colour as clearance? Freya wants current local advice and a plan matched to the group's capabilities before anyone commits. Callum wants to make good use of what looks like a favourable day.

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the full current bulletin and get appropriate local professional guidance before making this route decision. The Level 1 description still includes avalanche possibilities; the green tile cannot establish that the proposed outing suits them.

Being comfortable on their marked runs has not answered the separate questions they have about unpatrolled terrain. They need to assess those requirements honestly rather than use enthusiasm as evidence of preparation.

Callum can value a promising day without needing this particular route to be the outcome. The group could choose an activity within its established arrangements while investigating what a future outing would require.

Has everyone actually said they want to leave the marked runs, or has the discussion moved from one person's idea to a group commitment?

Ask each person before arranging anything. A qualified assessment of conditions would still leave individuals free to decline the outing; it should not be used to turn a hesitant friend's answer into an obligation.

Join the discussion

More in Travel