Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Does a 25% Lifetime ISA withdrawal charge only take back the bonus?

Money category photographMoney

I'm considering money for a car repair from a UK Lifetime ISA before age 60. This would be an ordinary non-qualifying withdrawal, not a first-home purchase or another charge-free situation. I haven't requested it.

Using illustrative figures with no growth or fees, I contributed £1,000 and received a £250 bonus, leaving £1,250. My partner expects the charge simply to remove the £250 bonus and leave my original £1,000. Applying 25% to the full balance seems to produce a different result.

What amount would actually be available under that calculation, and what should I confirm with the provider before using it in the repair budget?

Discussion

5 community replies

GOV.UK's withdrawal guidance applies the ordinary 25% charge to the amount withdrawn, including the bonus. On your illustrative £1,250 whole-pot withdrawal, that's £312.50, leaving £937.50 before any other relevant adjustments.

Adding 25% to £1,000 and then subtracting 25% of the larger amount aren't reverse operations. In this example, the result is £62.50 below the original contribution, so 'we only return the bonus' understates the cost.

Have the provider confirm the withdrawal category, actual balance, charges and payment timing for your circumstances. Keep the car-repair deadline beside that answer instead of treating the account's headline balance as confirmed spending money.

If we need only part of the pot, could we request exactly the repair amount and leave the charge to come from the remaining balance?

Ask the provider how the requested withdrawal and deduction are handled. The government guidance warns that a partial withdrawal needs to allow for the charge too. For an amount subject to a 25% deduction, the net cash is smaller than the gross amount withdrawn; don't promise the repair payment from the wrong figure.

Join the discussion

More in Money