Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Do we need to keep buying a small present for the child whose birthday it is not?

Parenting category photographParenting

My four-year-old asked what present he would get at his sister's birthday next week. For the past two years we have given each child a small gift on the other's birthday. It began as a way to get through the younger one's upset, and became something both expect.

My nine-year-old has now asked for her present-opening to be just hers. When I said her brother's small gift would not take anything away from her, she said she did not mean the amount of money. She wants one occasion when we are not preparing a matching consolation.

I am willing to stop the custom for both children. I also understand why my son expects it after we established it. I do not want him surprised with a new rule while everyone else is unwrapping things.

How would you change the arrangement while recognising that we created the expectation? I want both children included in the day without making both of them birthday children.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him before the party, plainly and kindly. “We have given extra presents before. We are changing that for both of you. This time the birthday presents are your sister's.” He does not have to agree that the old arrangement was a mistake.

Include him in an ordinary way if he wants: choosing a card, helping put out plates or joining the games. Do not turn inclusion into a job he must perform cheerfully to earn the right to be there.

Take your daughter's distinction seriously. She is asking about the occasion and attention, not disputing the value of two objects. You can support that without saying her brother's disappointment is her responsibility to prevent.

Check whether you have specifically promised your son a present for this birthday, beyond the general custom. If you have, address that promise honestly rather than telling him he imagined the arrangement. That may affect how you handle this year's transition.

That is a useful qualification. If there was an explicit promise, you could honour it this time while clearly ending the custom afterward, and still keep his sister's present-opening focused on her. If there was no such promise, give notice of the change and offer comfort without producing an emergency gift to end the disappointment.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting