Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Do two mirrored drives in a NAS mean our backup is finished?

Technology category photographTechnology

A friend set up two drives in our Synology NAS as RAID 1 and said the files were now backed up. I asked how we'd retrieve yesterday's version if someone deleted or overwrote the current one. We haven't established that.

Synology distinguishes RAID from a backup solution and describes separate protection for accidental deletion, corruption and storage failure. Synology's RAID note, NAS backup guidance

The shared project files are there and open correctly. What should we check before describing the arrangement as a recoverable backup, rather than assuming the second drive answers every kind of loss?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what protection was actually configured. Synology explicitly says RAID, including classic RAID, is not a backup solution. Redundancy for drive failure and recovering an earlier or deleted file are different capabilities. Synology's distinction

Check whether you have any versioned recovery arrangement, where it lives and what it includes. Synology describes several backup and snapshot tools; their presence in a product catalogue doesn't establish that your friend enabled and checked one. Backup options

Distinguish a local history on the same NAS from a copy that remains available if the NAS itself is lost or fails. Synology notes limits to protection kept on the same device. Decide which losses matter to this project before choosing the arrangement. Local-copy limits

Try retrieving a harmless sample through the proposed recovery route and inspect its contents. That would answer a more useful question than whether the NAS currently has two healthy-looking drives.

Restore the sample to a separate location so the check doesn't overwrite working material. Also record who can carry out that recovery. A successful demonstration by the only person who understands the setup leaves a different dependency unresolved.

Join the discussion

More in Technology