Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Do three articles count as independent evidence if they all repeat the same announcement?

Education category photographEducation

I had three links in the paragraph and felt well supported. Then I noticed that all three quoted the same council announcement.

My college report discusses a new community library. The articles have different site names and headlines, but their account of the opening and its intended benefits appears to come from that one statement. I haven't found reporting that separately checks those benefits.

The assignment asks for independent sources. I don't know whether that means separate publishers, different kinds of evidence or something more specific in this task. The announcement could still be useful for what the council said it intended to do.

How should I revise the source plan? I don't want to discard relevant information just because it has been repeated, or present three versions of one claim as three independent checks that it is true.

Discussion

5 community replies

The University of Cincinnati Libraries guide recommends tracing claims to the original source, including when an article is reporting what another source already wrote. Map what each article actually contributes before counting the links as separate support.

The announcement can support a sentence about the council's stated aims. That is a different use from proving those aims have been achieved. Keep the wording tied to the evidence you have actually found.

Different publishers might add independent observations or analysis, but you need to identify those additions. Do not assume they exist because the headline, layout or web address differs.

Show the tutor the three articles and the originating statement, and ask what the task means by independent sources. You may need to seek a different kind of evidence or narrow the question to something the available material can answer.

If the question changes, revise the conclusion as well as the reference list. A narrower account of the announced plans could be defensible where an evaluation of actual benefits is not yet supported. Adding another website that repeats the statement would not resolve that difference.

Join the discussion

More in Education