Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Do I need to retract a film criticism after finding out my friend made it?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I said, 'Whoever made this forgot to give it an ending.' My friend said, 'I made it.' We'd just watched a short film she brought to our group evening.

She hadn't introduced it as her work. I thought we were watching another small film she'd found, and I reacted as freely as I had to the others. I did find the ending abrupt. I also know my remark turned that reaction into a jab at the person who made it.

She says she wanted a response without everyone being polite because it was hers. Now I feel obliged to explain everything I liked, while she says she can't tell which compliments are real.

How do I apologise for the way I spoke without pretending my reaction to the ending has changed? I'd like to be a friend she can discuss her work with, rather than keep trying to cancel out one sentence with praise.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for making the criticism about the filmmaker, then explain that the ending felt abrupt to you. You can discuss that reaction without repeating the jab at the person who made it.

You don't have to produce a balanced review on the spot. Ask whether she wants to talk about the ending later, when neither of you is trying to repair the moment with more comments.

She chose to show it without introducing herself as the maker, which explains why your reaction wasn't cushioned. It doesn't require either of you to treat the wording as ideal feedback.

If you mention something you liked, choose a detail you really noticed before the reveal. A specific observation may be easier to trust than a sudden declaration that the whole film was wonderful.

And don't use the detail as a bargaining chip for forgiveness. It can be true that you liked a scene, disliked the ending and regret the way you expressed that dislike.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment