Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Do I need branded printer ink to keep the warranty?

Money category photographMoney

At a U.S. shop, the sales assistant warned that using any third-party ink cartridge would void my printer's entire warranty. Using illustrative prices, the branded cartridge is $45 and another seller's cartridge, labelled compatible with my model, is $20. I haven't bought either yet.

I'd pay more for a reason I understood. Paying more because of a sweeping warranty warning feels different. The FTC's warranty guidance says a manufacturer generally can't require specific parts or services to preserve coverage unless it supplies them free or has an FTC waiver. The same guidance also says warranty coverage has limits.

What should I ask the manufacturer or look for in the written warranty before treating the assistant's statement as a reason to pay the extra $25?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the written term behind 'the entire warranty is void.' That is a much broader statement than explaining which faults the warranty covers. Keep the exact printer model and cartridge details in the question so the answer addresses the purchase you're considering.

The FTC rule gives you a reason to question a blanket brand requirement, including whether either stated exception applies. It doesn't establish that the alternative cartridge is compatible or good value. Those are separate things to check before spending the $20.

Download the warranty and keep the receipt for whichever cartridge you choose. If the manufacturer's answer is unclear, ask it to distinguish using another brand from a problem attributed to that cartridge. A specific explanation is more useful than the shop's general warning.

So does that mean the cheapest cartridge is a safe choice because the manufacturer would still have to cover anything that went wrong?

No. A restriction on requiring branded parts isn't a promise about cartridge quality or coverage of every resulting problem. Check compatibility, the warranty's actual coverage and the seller's return terms. You might still choose the branded cartridge, but the decision shouldn't rest on that blanket warning alone.

Join the discussion

More in Money