Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Do I keep asking why when my child says he doesn’t know why he cut his T-shirt?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old cut a small triangle out of the T-shirt he was wearing while making paper decorations. It was his ordinary school-holiday shirt, not something we had agreed to alter. When I asked why, he said, ‘I don’t know.’

I kept asking. First he said he wanted to see whether the scissors would cut fabric, then that the shirt was too long. I said those explanations did not match. By then we were arguing about which answer was true rather than what had happened to the shirt.

I want him to take responsibility for using the scissors that way. I also realise I have made a satisfying explanation the condition for ending the conversation. I cannot tell whether he is avoiding an answer, trying out an explanation or simply unable to give me one I find convincing.

What would you ask next, and what would accountability look like if we never get a neat answer to ‘why’?

Discussion

5 community replies

You already know enough to discuss the immediate boundary: scissors were for the paper, and the shirt was cut without checking. A conversation about what happens to that shirt does not have to wait for a motive you can verify.

‘What were you doing just before you cut it?’ may give you something more concrete than another demand for why. Ask once, listen, and leave room for an incomplete account. This need not become a search for a confession.

Take care with treating the second explanation as proof that the first was false. Both could have crossed his mind, or neither may be a good account. You can say you are unsure without declaring that uncertainty dishonest.

The missing triangle may be the useful practical problem. Can he help decide whether the shirt is still wearable, needs a patch or becomes a craft shirt? That keeps responsibility connected to this particular action.

Yes, provided the repair is not presented as a way to earn release from more questioning. You could end the interrogation explicitly, then discuss the shirt together. Otherwise he may hear the patch as one more test he has to pass.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting