Do I keep asking why when my child says he doesn’t know why he cut his T-shirt?
ParentingMy nine-year-old cut a small triangle out of the T-shirt he was wearing while making paper decorations. It was his ordinary school-holiday shirt, not something we had agreed to alter. When I asked why, he said, ‘I don’t know.’
I kept asking. First he said he wanted to see whether the scissors would cut fabric, then that the shirt was too long. I said those explanations did not match. By then we were arguing about which answer was true rather than what had happened to the shirt.
I want him to take responsibility for using the scissors that way. I also realise I have made a satisfying explanation the condition for ending the conversation. I cannot tell whether he is avoiding an answer, trying out an explanation or simply unable to give me one I find convincing.
What would you ask next, and what would accountability look like if we never get a neat answer to ‘why’?