Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Do I have to repeat the accidental laugh I got in rehearsal?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

In our amateur play, my character admits that he lied to a friend. At rehearsal I forgot what came next and gave a tiny shrug after the confession. The cast laughed, and the director asked me to keep it.

I had been playing the scene as an uncomfortable attempt to be honest. Repeating the shrug deliberately makes it feel as though the character finds the lie amusing. The director says the laugh gives the audience a release and that I shouldn't fight a moment that works.

I haven't tried it in front of an audience, and a laugh from the cast doesn't settle how the scene will land. I want to raise the difference in intention without sounding as though I believe a serious scene is spoiled whenever anyone laughs. At the moment I'm reproducing an accident rather than knowing what my character is doing.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what the character is trying to achieve with the shrug. If it is an attempt to minimise the lie, you may be able to play that intention and see what follows. That gives you something more usable than an instruction to reproduce a laugh.

The director may want the audience to feel two things at once: amusement at the character's evasion and discomfort about the lie. Tell them what the gesture currently makes you feel, then ask whether that is the effect they intend.

Try the confession with and without the shrug in rehearsal, keeping the rest of the scene as consistent as you can. Talk about what each version does to the exchange with the friend. You don't have to settle the question by arguing about comedy in general.

What happens immediately after the laugh matters too. Does the other character challenge the confession, go quiet, or move on? You can look at that next beat with the director instead of treating the shrug as an isolated winning moment.

That would also give the actor playing the friend a place in the discussion. The beat belongs to the exchange, even if the laugh came from your gesture. A shared choice about what happens next could make it feel like a scene again rather than your obligation to deliver a reaction.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment