Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Do I have to leave the choir because the friend who brought me has quit?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My friend invited me to join a community choir last year. She has now left after a disagreement about changing the rehearsal night. The new night clashes with another commitment of hers, and she felt the committee decided too quickly.

I can still attend, and I enjoy singing there. When I mentioned the next concert, she said, "You only joined because of me. I thought you'd leave with me." I said I hadn't realised that was expected. She went quiet.

I know it hurts to lose an activity she loved, especially when I can carry on without the same clash. I also don't think my place in the choir should depend on her staying. I wasn't involved in the committee's discussion and can't honestly judge every part of how it was handled. How do I keep singing without making our friendship feel like the price of admission?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her that you understand why she is upset about the change and that you plan to stay. Leaving the decision vague may briefly avoid the awkwardness, but it leaves her expecting an act of solidarity you aren't planning to make.

For now, she might not want concert updates from you. Giving that subject some space would be a small kindness, especially while losing the choir still feels fresh. It doesn't require you to hide that you attend or to pretend you're equally unhappy there.

Ask what she felt you were agreeing to when she invited you. Was there ever a conversation about joining and leaving together, or is this expectation new? Her answer may explain the hurt even if it doesn't change your decision.

You can owe her gratitude for introducing you to the choir without owing her control over how long you stay. Say the grateful part out loud. "I'm glad you brought me, and it's become something I value too" is warmer than treating the original invitation as irrelevant.

The "too" matters there: the activity can have become yours while still carrying the history of going together. I'd avoid adding that she could simply find another choir. She hasn't asked you to solve the loss, and a replacement may not feel simple to her.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment