Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Do five measurements of one plant count as five experimental replicates?

Education category photographEducation

Our class project has two separately potted plants, one under each watering condition. We measured each plant on five days. My partner has labelled the table “five replicates per condition” because each column has five readings.

The American Society of Agronomy's introductory statistics material distinguishes the units assigned treatments from the observations measured, and discusses replication across subjects.

How should we describe what we actually did? I want to keep the five days of observations without implying that we treated five different plants in each condition. We have not yet asked the teacher what conclusions this design can support.

Discussion

5 community replies

The five readings describe the same plant at different times. They do not turn that plant into five separately treated plants. State both counts: one plant per condition, with measurements on five days.

Keep plant identity and measurement date clear in the table. Someone reading the report should be able to see which observations came from the same plant rather than infer five independent plants from five rows.

The observations need not disappear because the design has a limitation. You can describe how these particular plants changed while being careful about a broader claim that the watering condition caused the difference.

Ask the teacher to review the design and its limitations before choosing any statistical test. Do not try to make a familiar calculation fit by relabelling repeated readings as additional plants.

That discussion can also inform a future design: which units would receive each condition, what would be measured and what replication is feasible. Keep that proposal separate from the current report, whose sample description must match the plants you actually used.

Join the discussion

More in Education