Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Dad retired, but his Medicare surcharge uses older income. Can he ask for a review?

Money category photographMoney

Dad's Medicare notice includes an income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA. It uses income from a year when he was still working. He has now retired and is budgeting from a lower income, but he thinks he must wait for another tax return before anyone will look at the extra charge.

The Social Security Administration's Medicare guidance says work stoppage or reduced hours can be grounds for a new determination when income falls. It asks for evidence of the event and reduced income and describes Form SSA-44 as a way to request a reduction.

I'm helping him organise the papers, not assuming he'll qualify. What would make the request useful, and how do we keep his budget realistic while the decision is pending?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the notice: which tax year and income did SSA use, and what additional amount did it determine? That gives you a concrete comparison with the retirement date and the income information he wants SSA to consider.

An employer's retirement letter and records supporting the income reduction would address the two things SSA says it needs to verify. Follow the form's instructions for his situation rather than sending only a note saying his bank deposits are smaller.

It may help to explain that the earlier income figure isn't necessarily an error. The SSA guidance uses earlier tax information but also describes circumstances in which newer information can support another determination. He can ask about that route without accusing someone of misreading his return.

If he submits SSA-44, can he immediately budget as though the additional charge has gone? Otherwise it seems as though asking hasn't helped with the current squeeze.

A request isn't an approval or a confirmed new payment amount. Keep the notice's amount in the working budget while he asks SSA about the decision and payment instructions. If SSA changes it, update the budget from that determination rather than an expected result.

Join the discussion

More in Money