Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Can we decline to referee a couple's arguments during a three-person holiday?

Travel category photographTravel

“You know us both. Tell him I'm being reasonable,” Jo says across the breakfast table. Matt turns to Rhea and asks for her view too.

The three friends are on a four-day city break. Jo and Matt, who are a couple, disagree about how to spend the afternoon. Rhea was happy to discuss the choices as another traveller. The conversation has become an argument about whose preferences always come first, with both sending her private messages about the other.

Rhea has a place on an afternoon walk and wants to leave on time. She can say what she would enjoy doing, but does not want to deliver a verdict about their relationship. Jo says refusing to answer makes her feel unsupported; Matt says Rhea should at least acknowledge his side.

Can Rhea go on her walk and leave them to discuss it, while still being a friend to both? She does not want the rest of the trip to become two separate campaigns for her agreement.

Discussion

5 community replies

Rhea could say, “I'll discuss what the three of us do this afternoon, but I won't decide which of you is the unreasonable partner.” Then she can leave for the walk at the time she planned, without making departure depend on their agreement.

Jo and Matt may each want reassurance more than a verdict. Rhea can recognise that either is disappointed without confirming the account they have sent privately about the other. Otherwise the same breakfast argument will simply move into two message threads.

They should also remember Rhea has paid for a holiday of her own. Asking her opinion on an outing is ordinary group planning; repeatedly requiring her to sort out their disagreement takes time from the trip she chose.

Are they asking for help choosing between two activities, or asking her to validate a much older grievance? Rhea could participate in a practical plan as one of the three travellers while declining the second role.

That distinction gives her something clear to offer. She can state her own preference and availability without deciding whose past complaints are justified. Jo and Matt would then need to make their choices without treating her afternoon as a hearing they are entitled to finish.

Join the discussion

More in Travel