Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Can we decline to post a holiday review that a friend has written for everyone?

Travel category photographTravel

Leon sends two enthusiastic paragraphs to the holiday chat: “Copy this into your reviews. It'll save everyone time.”

The friends have just finished a walking tour. Leon loved it and wants to support the guide. Saira enjoyed the first half but found the later stops rushed. She would not choose the same praise or overall assessment, and does not want the words posted under her name.

Leon thinks she is making a small favour difficult. He is happy to fix the wording, but assumes they will all give the same verdict because they attended together.

What should Saira say? She can decide whether to review the tour and describe her own view if she does. She wants to keep that choice without turning the final evening into an argument over whether the guide deserves support.

Discussion

5 community replies

Saira can thank Leon for offering and say she will write her own review if she decides to leave one. Being on the same tour did not give the friends identical impressions.

Leon can express his enthusiasm in his own account without recruiting everyone else to repeat it. Support is more meaningful when the words reflect what the person posting them actually thinks.

Saira does not have to exaggerate the rushed portion to justify refusing the draft. Enjoying some of the tour and feeling less positive about the rest is a complete view in itself.

Would Leon offer editing help only when a friend asks for it next time? Somebody might welcome help making their own words clearer while still wanting to choose the content and verdict.

That would preserve the useful part of his offer. He could help Saira express what she means, if invited, without treating her different experience as a wording problem to be corrected until it matches his.

Join the discussion

More in Travel