Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Can we call our puzzle finished if we've only watched each other solve it?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

A friend and I made a paper puzzle for a birthday gathering. We know the answer, the intended route and what every odd-looking mark is meant to suggest. When we tested it on each other, we both reached the answer quickly.

I want to ask someone who hasn't helped make it to try the puzzle before we print copies. My friend says that will spoil the surprise for one of our guests and that we're overthinking a party game. She wants to print tonight.

There is one clue I only understand because I remember our earlier draft. I haven't said that plainly; I've been calling for "more testing" as if I had a general rule behind me. I think we need one fresh attempt, but I also don't want a birthday activity to become a development project.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the actual clue. "I think I understand this because I remember the old draft" is a much more useful reason to pause than an unexplained demand for testing. Your friend can then look at the same uncertainty rather than defending the whole puzzle.

A test can stay small: one willing person who didn't help write it, using the version you intend to print. Give them the instructions guests would receive, and note where they ask for information. You don't have to turn their attempt into a score or a verdict on your work.

Is there someone outside the birthday guest list who would enjoy trying it? That might preserve the surprise for your guests. If there isn't, you and your friend can decide whether one person knowing the puzzle early is an acceptable trade-off.

Agree in advance what you would do with the result. If the person gets stuck at that clue, would you rewrite it, add a hint, or accept that it is meant to be difficult? A fresh solver won't settle a disagreement about the kind of game you're trying to make.

And a fast solve wouldn't certify that every guest will find it clear. It would give you one useful attempt at this draft. Keeping that modest expectation might help your friend see a short check rather than an endless approval process.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment