Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Can we ask a friend to use an unretouched holiday group photo?

Travel category photographTravel

Sam opens the group photograph and notices his face looks different. His friend Luca confirms that he smoothed skin and changed facial details while editing the holiday album. He says he did it for everyone so they would all have flattering pictures.

Sam likes the photograph and wants a copy of the original. He also asks Luca to use a version without the changes to his face when sharing the album more widely. Some of the other friends like the retouched version.

Luca has spent hours sorting the pictures and feels his work is being treated as an insult. He says he was trying to be kind, not suggesting anything was wrong with Sam's appearance. Sam believes that intention but still does not want the altered face to represent him.

How can they decide what to share without making everyone judge which version of Sam looks better? Sam would like the conversation to stay about his preference for his own image, rather than turn into reassurance he did not ask for.

Discussion

5 community replies

Luca can send Sam the original first. That would meet a straightforward request without making the file depend on Sam accepting the edits as a compliment. They can discuss the wider album separately.

The other friends can like their own retouched pictures. Their preference does not tell Sam how he must feel about changes to his face. There is room for different choices without voting on whose appearance benefits most.

Sam could make the request specific: keep his facial features as photographed in anything they agree to share of him. That would avoid a wider argument about whether every adjustment to light or colour is objectionable.

Luca did put work into taking and sorting the pictures. Sam can appreciate that effort while explaining the particular change he does not want. Gratitude and agreement about retouching are different things to discuss.

Yes. Thanking Luca for the photographs should not mean Sam has withdrawn his request. Luca could ask how to handle Sam's image in the shared version, rather than make acceptance of the altered face the proof that his effort was valued.

Join the discussion

More in Travel