Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Can reinvested dividends create a tax bill even if I withdraw nothing?

Money category photographMoney

My U.S. taxable brokerage account is set to reinvest dividends automatically. Using an illustrative transaction, a $100 ordinary cash dividend buys $100 of additional shares at their market value. My partner thinks there's no income to report because no money reaches our bank account. I've been thinking about it the same way.

The IRS guidance on reinvested dividends says dividends used to buy shares at fair market value still have to be reported as income. I haven't checked the account's tax documents or how we'd cover any tax due.

I like the automatic setting, but I don't want 'nothing withdrawn' to become our tax plan. What records and cash needs should we check before deciding whether to keep reinvesting?

Discussion

5 community replies

Look for the dividend in the broker's tax documents as well as the reinvestment in the transaction history. In this example, receiving a dividend and using it to buy shares are two steps, even if the account handles both without sending cash to your bank.

Don't turn the $100 dividend into a guessed tax bill. Reporting income doesn't tell you your eventual tax amount by itself. Review the relevant documents with the rest of your tax situation, using qualified help if needed.

The cash question is worth discussing before changing the setting. If tax is due, would you cover it from money elsewhere, or would you prefer some dividends paid out as cash? Neither preference is settled just by the convenience of automatic reinvestment.

If the new shares arrived through reinvestment instead of a bank transfer, do they count as free shares with a zero cost basis when they're eventually sold?

Reinvestment doesn't make their cost zero. The IRS guidance describes basis for shares bought through a dividend reinvestment plan as their cost, with applicable adjustments. Keep the purchase records for those new shares; don't infer basis from whether cash passed through your bank account.

Join the discussion

More in Money